Surly Cross-Check Review 2024- Should You Try This Hybrid Bike?

Is this bike from Surly Worth it? The Surly Cross Check Bike is one of the newest additions to hit the market. In this review we will be discussing the new bike in detail, going through all of its structure, how it feels to ride it, who it is best for, and other burning questions about the bike.

If you know your way around bicycles then the name Surly would sure come to mind. Surly is one of the best bike manufacturers out there, they know how to produce the best-performance bikes that you can get for your money. Customers and the whole industry know that the bikes from Surly are known for their amazing performance and the value you get!

Surly has many amazing models that you will find in their portfolio, although the Surly Cross-Check bike fully stands out as it is strong and very comfortable to ride. If you are comfortable enough then there is no better option than the Surly Cross-Check, although if you have doubts then the best approach is to gather all the needed information first!

The Surly Cross-Check is without a doubt an amazing bike, but let us get you fully introduced to it, we don’t need any gray lines here. First of all, it is a cyclocross bike, but not just any cyclocross bike, the Surly Cross-Check can be fully customized to your personal preferences, you can even make it one of those gravel bikes that are the fire these days. The ability of all this customization makes it one of the best bikes to have, this bike will surely max out your cycling experience!

Surly Cross Check Bike
Surly Cross-Check Bike

The Surly Cross-Check brings you the best of both worlds as it is a hybrid between road bikes and mountain bikes. You get amazing speed, stability, and comfort all in one, what else could you want? These are all the things that you would actually want in a mountain bike, if you want more, you can always customize it!

Let us now examine the features of the Surly Cross-Check bike:

Features and Components

The Surly Cross-Check bike has the following features and components:

  • Frame: Surly Cross-Check, Surly 4130 CroMoly steel
  • Fork: Surly Cross-Check, 4130 CroMoly, lugged and brazed.
  • Seatpost: Surly stainless, 30.0mm
  • Headset: Cane Creek Custom 5
  • Brakes: Tektro M730 V-brake
  • Brake Levers: Tektro RL520
  • Shifters: Micro shift BS-M10, bar-end shifter
  • Stem: HL 31.8
  • Handlebars: Salsa Cowbell 3
  • Grip/Tape: Black Cork
  • Saddle: WTB Volt Support/ Kalloy
Surly Cross Check Gears
Surly Cross Check Gears

Drivetrain Components

  • Crankset: Shimano CX50, 36/46t
  • Bottom bracket: Shimano 4600
  • Front derailleur: Shimano Tiagra 4600
  • Rear derailleur: Shimano Deore T610-SGS
  • Cog or cassette: Shimano CS-HG50-10, 11-32, 10-speed
  • Chains: KMC X10


  • Front hub: Shimano Deore T610, 32h, 100mm, w/QR
  • Rear hub: Shimano Deore T610, 32h, 135mm, w/QR
  • Rims: Alex Adventurer 2, tubeless-ready

Surly Cross-Check Geometry Specifications

In order to be satisfied with your bike purchase to need to know the full specifications and geometry of it. Your research will play a very important part when you actually get the bike and start using it. When it comes to geometry, you can always find charts on the manufacturer’s website. In order to see the geometry specifications of the Surly Cross-Check, click here.


  • The Surly Cross-Check is constructed with a steel frame that isn’t just durable but very strong
  • You will see that this bike is equipped with a higher-than-road bottom bracket. This means that the bike will retain its effectiveness when you ride it off the beaten path.
  • The Surly Cross-Check is also known as the “Gravel Crusher”.  The bike is able to perform well on any kind of terrain, that’s why it is an amazing hybrid between road and mountain bikes. The Surly Cross-Check will be perfect if you take it out for normal routines or some off-road adventures.
  • You get amazing wheel versatility thanks to the gnot-rite dropout spacing. You can even install fatter tires on the bike if you feel like it.
  • You can get the bike in three different but amazing colors: Sage green, black, and mustard. 


  • The Surly Cross-Check may be strong but it is also quite heavy.
  • If you are seeking a fast ride that is also light, then the Surly Cross-Check isn’t the best choice. The bike isn’t that agile.

Unique Features of The Surly Cross-Check That Stand Out

Surly Cross Check Breaks
Surly Cross Check Breaks

The Surly Cross-Check has some unique selling points that make it distinct from the other bikes out there:

  • You will notice that the Surly Cross-Check has semi-horizontal dropouts. This means that you can easily adjust the wheelbase however you see fit and they will also give you single-speed compatibility which is very necessary.
  • The bike has gnot-rite dropout spacing, which means that you can install hubs on the bike that range between 130mm and 135mm.
  • Last but not least, you can freely install front and rear fenders and racks. With these equipped you can easily make your build advanced and beefier, it won’t just look fancy but also perform the part.

Before You Buy!

There is some advice that you need to hear before you buy the Surly Cross-Check! First of all, the bike costs between $925 and $1149, these prices will vary on the additional accessories that you buy from or different retailers. The bike is featured as highly versatile and it is so, there are tons of customization options that you can apply. It does not matter if it is off-road trails or a daily routine, this bike will certainly not disappoint.

Why Was The Surly Cross-Check Designed?

Surly Bike
Surly Bike

Most bikes are made for different and multiple purposes, this was not the case when the Surly Cross-Check came out. The Surly Cross-Check was marketed as “The Gravel-Eating Beast”. It had an amazing performance on hilly and rough terrains, and it was doing quite well when compared to other bikes. Now there are many variants available, they aren’t that good if we compare them to modern mountain bikes. Yes, the gravel-killing prowess is still there but it hasn’t been refined I would say.

We can compare the Cross-Check to a really good road bike though because both of them offer great maneuverability and responsiveness. If you are a technical rider then you would also be in luck because it does a fairly good enough job than other mountain bikes out there. This is a hybrid bike, so it is actually designed to do everything, no matter if they are pavements to hit or off-road trails, this bike is going to do an amazing job. In my personal opinion, the bike can be safely titled as a jack of all trades but master of none.

Exploring The Surly Cross-Check’s Construction and Weight

The Surly Cross-Check is one big chunk of a bike, it is heavy, let us discuss how heavy it actually is and what it means!

The frame of the bike is exactly 2.2 kg (56cm model) it isn’t much but when you add the whole construction into it, it gets heavier. Usually, bike frames are made from a variety of materials, like carbon and aluminum. The Surly Cross-Check is going to be heavier as it uses a different kind of construction. The steel used here is very different from regular steel, it is more durable and stronger. Chromoly steel may be compared to titanium but in some aspects, it is better than that, for example, it doesn’t need to go through an extensive manufacturing process and it cannot be damaged easily.

You will also find out that frames made from Chromoly Steel are more responsive and durable.

Apart from all this, when getting the Surly Cross-Check, you have two options. Either you can get the frame or the complete bike. There are pros and cons to both options so let’s discuss them.

Pros of Buying Frame

  • The first benefit that you get from getting the frame is the customizable options. Think of them as a skeleton, you can customize the bike to your heart’s content, think of all this as building a pc from scratch, the possibilities are endless. You can have a nice balance here if you want to save money or go ham.
  • There are chances that sometimes you won’t fully be satisfied with your bike build, by getting a frame you can remove the components that you don’t like and replace them with those of your liking. 
  • You get tons of flexibility by getting a frame, you are not bound to only one design.
Surly Cross-Check Frame
Surly Cross-Check Frame

Cons of Buying Frame

  • Building a bike from scratch isn’t easy though, you need to have top-of-the-line tools available and they don’t come cheap. If you have friends that are professionals in this line of work then consider it as the cherry on top.
  • It isn’t convenient to build a bike, the majority of the people out there love getting the complete bike.
  • The building process isn’t actually fun or quick, it can be very stressful at times. There will be many mistakes made and you will have to be extraordinarily patient with the process if you want it to be successful.

Pros of Complete Bike

  • You get a bike for yourself and all of those worries go away, you will be relaxed and satisfied with your purchase. When you build a bike yourself, there is a chance sometimes that some of the parts may not work. When you purchase a complete bike, all of the parts work in sync to give you the best performance available!
  • You can try it right away, just purchase the bike and get started with it as soon as you get home.
  • If you lack bike knowledge then the best thing to do is get the complete bike rather than start building one as it would be the easiest and safe option.

Surly Cross-Check Bikes

Cons of Complete Bike

  • If you buy the complete bike then you have to make do with the bike parts that the manufacturer provided!
  • Getting a complete bike is expensive when compared to building a bike, you have to keep that in mind when you go for that option!

Surly Cross Check: Performance Review (2023)

The Surly Cross-Check is an amazing bike, that’s for sure but how does it perform on the road? That’s what we are going to discuss with you.

On-Road Performance 

We have to tell you this, on the road this bike performs like an absolute beast. The Surly Cross-Check allows clearance for up to 42C tires, this means that you can fit this bike with some beefy tires. When fitted with the tires, you can crush almost anything standing in your way. We tested it out on paved roads and got to our destination within minimal time (With Traffic). Overall, it proves to be a good steel commuter bike that you can also use as a touring bike.

Why should you go with larger tires? Well for starters, their performance becomes great because you can run them at lower pressures. No matter what, you are going to enjoy an amazing ride.

Off-Road Performance 

You can use the Surly Cross-Check for some cross racing but I wouldn’t recommend that you use the bike only for that purpose. Its steel frame is of low quality, especially when you compare it with other steel bikes, this increases the weight of the bike which becomes troubling when you venture into rough and technical terrain. The weight penalty is something that you will actually feel on your rides and can’t be ignored.

In conclusion, the Surly Cross-Check can do some cross racing but if you plan on using it for only a cross-racing machine then I would suggest that you get another bike.

On-Trail Performance 

The On-Trail Performance is the most balanced performance in my opinion. The handlebars respond well, the bike stays balanced and I get to ride like I wanted from the start. I tried this bike on crushed gravel trails and the result was pretty impressive, I have to say. The front and rear racks of the bike also do a great job this time around.

The bike actually finds its calling on gravel trails, it excels as a gravel bike, and I am more than fine to use it like that. The bike becomes amazingly responsive, absorbs the vibrations, and leaves the rider wanting more adventures. 

Is it What You Were Looking For?

For whom would the Surly Cross-Check be best suitable? That is a complicated question that we will answer. If you are one of those cyclists that want a great multi-purpose bike then the Surly Cross-Check is a great option for you. It is a highly durable bike with some of the best components you can find. It is constructed with a Shimano drivetrain and has Tektro bakes, what else could you want?

Surly Cross Check
Surly Cross Check

It may be a really good hybrid bike but it isn’t a racing bike, the Chromoly frame makes the bike heavier for any kind of race. Also, if you are getting the Surly only for the purpose of a mountain bike then it will not be a good choice, this bike comes in between but never excels as a dedicated option. It is a great bike for experimentation though, you can use it for a variety of reasons, and it will not disappoint you there. If you go with the full package then it can serve as an amazing first complete bike, although not good as a mountain bike, you can use it as a touring bike if you wish. In the case of any customizations, you can take Surly Cross-Check to a local bike shop. 

If you are looking for a bike with exceptional performance but are not willing to spend thousands on a specialized bike then definitely go for the Surly Cross-Check.

A User’s Perspective and Other Feedback

Reviews are one thing but getting an actual user’s experience with the bike is another thing. I too am a user and I rounded up many reviews about this bike from my team and other people.

Surly Cross Check Breaks
Surly Cross Check Breaks

These were their experiences:

“The bike’s performance is amazing, its durability makes it perfect for multiple purposes. Although the bike isn’t for races, we can certainly take it out for a marathon. This bike is heavy and that is why it might not be that appealing to some people but other than that everything is great! The customization options also make this bike quite flexible and fun to use.”

“Attractive color for a woman like me. This bike is no exception. The fit – This frame fits great – no problems there. Versatility – there isn’t anything I can do on this bike that doesn’t work – tour, ride, road, fire trails, single/doubel track going to Brick Masonry place. With that said, it feels a bit heavy for me.”

rosendamanns2808 (Bought The Surly Cross-Check)

“The biggest upside to this bike is also in its way its downside. The cross-check is amazingly versatile. I have owned a few now, and always keep one in my fleet. I use it several times a week for a variety of different applications. Often it is a single track with cross tires, but sometimes road centuries, the commuting, shop runs, and the occasional local cyclocross race. The price you pay for this versatility is a long wheelbase, a long chain stay, and a frameset that is not a featherweight. Apart from that, it is not the lightest thing in the world. Several paint schemes are largely uninspiring. The rear brake cable contacts the top tube when you stand over it.”

maxloewenstein (Bought The Surly Cross-Check)

Alternatives and Competitors

The Surly Cross-Check is an amazing bike, but there are chances that this couldn’t be the right bike for you. We take a look at some alternatives to the Surly to give you plenty of choices to choose from!

Giant ToughRoad SLR 2

The Giant ToughRoad SLR 2 is one sturdy bike, its frame is made from aluminum. What you get is an extremely light bike that is also agile, you will be able to do well in any kind of terrain. Comparatively, this bike has more stack as it has exactly 556mm. You will experience more comfort than on the Surly Cross-Check!

When it comes to stack, the Surly has the upper hand (394.8mm), having a long bike makes it easy to handle any kind of terrain while achieving top speed. The SLR 2 also has a longer chainstay which is 429mm long. The headtube length of this bike is also longer, clocking in at 12.9cm.

DiamondBack Haanjo Comp

 This bike has a frame made out of carbon fiber, it may not be as strong as steel but that doesn’t mean it’s useless, it has exclusive benefits. This makes the bike have a lower density, which protects it from bumps on the road. The Diamondback Haanjo Comp has a very impressive stack of 543mm.

The Surly has a longer reach tho so keep that in mind. Although the Diamondback still wins when it comes to chainstay as it is 430mm. The headtube is also longer (15.5cm).

Cannondale Synapse Carbon 105SE

This is where it gets interesting, the frame of the Cannondale is made from BallisTec carbon. It is strong, stiff, but also very light which makes it unique. This is a bike that is definitely easier to handle!

This bike has a stack of 610mm which is more than that of the Surly Cross-Check. Both the bikes have the same reach though! Cannondale actually focuses on comfort more so it has a shorter chainstay which is just 410mm. The headtube length of the Cannondale is 19.7cm making it way longer than that of the Surly Cross-Check.

Trek CrossRip 2

The CrossRip 2 from Trek is a great bike and is in the middle when it comes to the CrossRip series. It is cheaper than other entries but the performance is comparatively better. The CrossRip 2 can be compared to the Surly Cross-Check because it too can handle a lot of terrains, but sometimes it becomes less effective

Both of these bikes almost have the same components but Surly does a better job of actually using those components. Although with that said the CrossRip 2 is lighter.

Surly Straggler

Why not compare the Surly Cross-Check to another bike from Surly, I thought that the Straggler would be a great choice for comparison. Keep in mind that the Straggler is a variant of the Cross-Check and comes constructed with disc brakes. The inclusion of disc brakes makes the Straggler better at handling off-road trails.

The tires of the Straggler can also be further customized to get better clearance.


The Surly Cross-Check is a bike that is made for all-terrain, you can use it comfortably for daily routines or off-road adventures. The bike also gives you a variety of customizable options, you can get the frame or the bike completely. Each option has its own benefits so choose carefully!

If you want an amazing all-rounder bike, the Surly Cross-Check should definitely be your next bike!

Also Read:

Should you have any questions or require further clarification on the topic, please feel free to connect with our expert author Rhodes Perry by leaving a comment below. We value your engagement and are here to assist you.

For the latest content and updates please follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Pinterest.

Rhodes Perry

Rhodes Perry

Rhodes is a writer, social justice advocate, and passionate cyclist. He primarily spends his time in the saddle commuting or riding multi-day, self-supported tours, and volunteers time wrenching at his local bike coop.


Leave a Comment