How to Choose Between Winter Cycling Gloves, Pogies and Mittens

Winter Cycling Gloves, Pogies and Mittens are all great options. So which one do you choose?

Besides the fact that they are out in the cold and the wind chill, your hands are also locked in the same position on the bike for your entire ride. This can reduce circulation and you can get really cold hands, perhaps frostbitten in short order.

Many options help you cover your hands in the cold. You can choose either Winter Cycling Gloves, Pogies and Mittens.

Choosing Between Winter Cycling Gloves, Pogies and Mittens

Here is the good part; I have used all these and here is an in-depth review of each type which can help you decide which option suits you the best. 

1. Winter Cycling Gloves

Winter cycling glovesIn the last few years, there have been some really warm hand gear appearing on the market, specifically designed for cycling. These usually contain some form of neoprene combined with other materials, usually in layers.

Examples include Performance Neoprene Cycling Gloves and Specialized Sub-zero gloves (right). These are designed for fairly cold weather, although not as cold as the typical icebiker experiences. Remember that these are race-oriented companies.

A more realistic approach is taken by Lake, with their MXZero Winter Cycling Glove. It has a wind and water-resistant outer, and a fleece inner glove that can be removed for cleaning. It even has a vent zipper on the back if it’s just too hot. Note that this feature can keep you from drenching your gloves with sweat. The palm is designed for cycling with reinforcements in all the right places.

2. Three Finger Gloves

Soecialized three finger glovesSome of the warmest hand gear produced by a cycling company was the Specialized Lobster Claws.

A similar product is the Nashbar Penguin Glove and the Pearl Izumi Stretch Amfib. These are three-fingered gloves. Two fingers in each segment and your thumb in the other.

The Idea behind three fingers is that each finger has a mate to keep it warm, and there is less exposed surface. Your thumb must fend for itself. They have a fleece liner and a layer of foam with a terry cloth back cover (guess why), they do not breathe well, and moisture can build up, but turning them inside out to dry keeps them fairly fresh.

With the Performance Claws, my hands usually sweat even when the temperature is about Zero(F). I don’t wear them until it is well below freezing as they are just too warm. I don’t see them listed on the Specialized web page, but I found them in the LBS as late as 3/97, and they are featured on the back of the Nashbar late fall 97 catalog.

An even more aggressive design is the Vulpine Adaptive Icebike Mitt. These are very warm and roomy winter mitts suitable for expedition conditions, or extended outings. These have a full zipper access and a reflective patch for traffic safety.

 Check out the freeze-tested winter cycling clothes reviewed in the article. These clothes will keep you warm and comfortable during your winter rides

3. Pogies

Pogies mittens for winter cyclingAnother solution is Pogies. Bike pogies are oversized mittens that fit over the handlebars. They let you ride barehanded when you’d wear gloves and let you wear gloves when you’d need heavy mittens or gloves.

They attach to the handlebar covering the brake and shift levers, which means you can operate these in comfort. If you use more than one bike, you either have to move the pogies with you (demount and re-mount each time) or get another pair.

Several icebikers report that pogies are the warmest solution they have found. Pictured here is Charles Beristain’s full suspension C’dale with pogies mounted. You put your hands in the large opening at the rear, and the pogie forms a natural wind barrier that protects your hand and part of your forearm.

Pogies mittens for winter cyclingI’ve lightened the photo to the point of a washout so that you can see where your hands are inserted. Note that there is ample clearance for brake and shift levers inside each Pogie.

The second picture shows the pogies from the front. Note the reflective piping for night visibility.

Now if someone would just send Charlie some snow…

All Weather Sports sells pogies, and you can probably order then through any good LBS. If they don’t know where to get them just send them here to Icebike.org.

4. Moose Mitts

Moose mittsMoose Mitts is another manufacturer of pogie-like handlebar mittens.

Available online, these handlebar mitts include an internal pocket to keep keys cell phones, or anything else you want handy and warm. They cost about $80 per pair and are available in a selection of colors. Made of 400 Denier Cordura provides a strong, abrasion-resistant material, which is also coated with water-repellent, and windproof.

Fleece Lining Provides a warm environment for those digits. Once the internal area gets warm from your hands they stay that way.

5. Auxillary heat

In seriously cold environments where prolonged exposure is planned, such as a winter camping trip or day-long trail rides, you may want to take along some backup protection.

One option is chemical hand-warming devices. These generate prolonged gentle heat and are safe to place inside your gloves. They work via an oxidation process, using powdered iron and salt water. Safe for the environment, they are said to last 7 hours.

How To Choose The Right Glove- Buying Guide

So, whichever option you decide to go with, keep an eye out for the following features:

  • The glove should have a snug fit on your hand. It should not be either too loose or too tight. 
  • You should be able to control the handlebar and operate the brakes. There should be enough sensitivity. 
  • Make sure that they have the right padding. 
  • Winter cycling gloves should be warm. But they shouldn’t be bulky like the ones you use for skiing. 
  • Mittens are warmer but they offer less sensitivity. So it might be hard for you to control the handlebar. 

FAQs

Which are better gloves or mittens?

Gloves are better because they offer better sensations. This helps you control the handlebar better. 

What is the best material for cycling gloves?

Fleece, polyester, acrylic, and polypropylene are best for winter cycling. For summers, it’s better to use light and breathable gloves. 

Should cycling gloves be padded?

Yes, padded cycling gloves are more comfortable. 

Conclusion

During the early fall or late spring, a set of light cloth gloves under your cycling gloves is all that you need. Full-fingered gloves made for cycling are generally ok down to freezing, but beyond that, you are going to need something warmer.

In years past, the only way you could reliably keep your fingers warm was by switching to ski gloves. These are designed with the fact that the hand will be locked in the same position all day too, except around a ski pole rather than a handlebar. Any warm ski glove should give good service, and I use them to this day on some rides.

Let me know what you think in the comments below!

Also Read

 


This article was crafted by John Andersen, a seasoned expert, bringing years of experience and knowledge about all types of bikes. Our goal is to provide you with accurate, reliable, and valuable insights to help you make informed decisions and enhance your biking experience.

Should you have any questions or require further clarification on the topic, please feel free to connect with our expert author John Andersen by leaving a comment below. We value your engagement and are here to assist you.

For the latest content and updates please follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Pinterest.

Related

Leave a Comment