10 Reasons Why Cities Should Consider Going Car-Free

We buy and receive free products to review, and may receive commissions from affiliate links. See our disclosure page for details.

Our climate is changing, and time is running out to take thoughtful action. If you’re like me, you may feel powerless in defending yourself and those that you love from the negative impacts of climate change.

Despite our fears, the Union of Concerned Scientists suggests that at the most individual level we can positively impact the environment by taking three basic actions:

Car free street party

A handful of smaller communities embrace the concept of driving less by banning personal cars within their city limits – granted, most of these communities are small island towns that thrive on tourism.

While most of the world’s major cities aren’t quite ready to embrace emission-cutting tactics like banning personal cars, this article presents 10 reasons why they should.

If the fate of the world’s environment isn’t compelling enough, the following argument is broken down to personal and economic gains possible if personal cars were banned in major cities:

  • Cultivating a Culture of Happiness. As a dedicated bike commuter, I have discovered a very basic truth – cycling or walking to work is a much more pleasant experience that results in a greater level of happiness and well-being as compared to driving or taking public transportation.The higher happiness factor has a lot to do with exercise and the relief of avoiding being squished next to complete strangers on the subway, or being caught in traffic with aggressive and unhappy drivers on the roadways. My personal experience is backed up by science. Studies have found that cycling and walking trump any other form of transportation to work when it comes to measuring “happiness.”

    When people are happier due to exercise from commuting, they are more productive, and less likely to become stressed, anxious, or depressed. A happier, less stressed, and healthier society is good for everyone.

Man riding cycle to office

  • Improved Physical Fitness. Those traveling cities by foot or bike will also experience significant benefits to their physical fitness. Improvements include a reduction of the stress hormone Cortisol, and a boost in immunity. In fact, researchers from the Loughborough University’s Sleep Research Centre found that cycling helps get your circadian rhythm back in sync, which rids the body of Cortisol, the stress hormone.Less stress leads to a deeper, more regenerative sleep that helps strengthen the body’s immunity. Maintaining a regular schedule of walking or biking triggers the release of dopamine, which is linked to energy. More dopamine in the brain helps ward off feelings of sluggishness or fatigue. A study from the University of Georgia confirmed this assertion when they studied the effects of bike riding and found that it improved energy levels by 20 percent and decreased fatigue by 65%.
  • Enhancing Mindfulness & Creativity. Exercising before work, whether by foot or pedal power, helps improve focus, clarity, and creativity. By taking as much as 25 minutes out of your day and dedicating it to aerobic exercise, the time away from the pressures of your work “to-do” list will boost creative thinking and clarity on what is important now.A study from the University of Illinois confirms this assertion. Specifically, it found that cycling enhances cardio-respiratory fitness, which translates into an even higher boost to an individual’s brainpower. This form of exercise increases the flow of blood and oxygen to the brain, and promotes the production of new brain cells in the hippocampus. This region of the brain is responsible for our memory.
  • Building Stronger Communities. Leaving the personal car at home, and embracing walking or biking about town as an alternative transportation method increases the likelihood that you’ll soon be socializing with your neighbors and friends along your chosen route.A University of Michigan study found that just 10 minutes of social interaction a day helps improve an individual’s cognitive performance by limiting isolation. The art of socializing is found to increase oxytocin reserves, which buffer the “fight or flight” response, and instead cultivates the “tend and befriend” response. Socializing also lowers stress hormones according to a landmark UCLA study.

    Getting to know our neighbors, and getting more engaged with our communities limits feelings of isolation, and develops more connected and stronger communities.

No cars in Copenhagen

  • Innovating New “Green” Markets. More incentives and safer transportation pedestrian and cycling routes inevitably leads to emerging markets with new demands. Motivate and B-Cycle are two such companies benefiting from these new markets.Combined these two companies alone are the fastest growing “green” businesses in the country. They have made a substantial impact on the lives of tens of thousands of cyclists, as they manage bike share operations in roughly 40 U.S. cities. More broadly, the bike sharing industry has experienced the fastest growth of any mode of transport in the history of the planet.

    There’s much hope for this new industry to spawn off other innovation to meet the demands for the emerging urban cycling market. Bicycle franchises like Velofix, mobile retailers like the Bike Smith, and even mechanics like Ben Wyse who pedal directly to their clients, are innovating new solutions to the growing demands this market.

  • Growing Local Businesses. After nearly 50 years of centralizing automobiles in urban centers, city planners are now designing “complete streets” that include protected bike lanes. Including dedicated bike lanes in street redesigns greatly boosts retail performance for local businesses.In fact, after the completion of a protected bike lane on 9th Avenue in New York, local retailers experienced a 49 percent increase in sales compared to other streets in Manhattan that were averaging only 3 percent. In a number of other cities with protected bicycle lanes, studies found that cyclists spend the same amount of money per month compared to people who arrive by car, though they tend to make smaller purchases and return more often.
  • Location, Location, Location. As someone who prioritizes living on streets with protected bike lanes, I can say with great confidence that property value is significantly enhanced if you are lucky enough to score a home built on a complete street. Those brave enough to live along Times Square’s pedestrian and bicycle paths found that property values increased by 71 percent in 2010 alone. Since this is the greatest rise in property values in the City, some infer this rise in property values was the result of the construction of these paths.According to one Indiana University study, the value of properties within one block of the Indianapolis Cultural Trail – a converted railway transformed into a protected bicycle and pedestrian path – increased 148 percent after construction – more than doubling in value from 2008 to 2015. In other words, what seemed like a significant public and private investment of $63 million ended up generating $1 billion in additional assessed property value.

Biking the car free city

  • Safer Streets for Everyone. Limited cars and protected bicycle lanes makes traveling by foot much safer. This is because the distance to cross a street is shortened for pedestrians to make a safe crossing at an intersection due to the addition of bicycle lanes on both sides of the street.Cyclists are also less likely to get in accidents with pedestrians or cars because they have a dedicated space on the road to ride, and are less likely to weave in-and-out of traffic and cars and pedestrians know where to find cyclists – in the protect bike lane. Studies verify cyclists are more inclined to ride on the streets, obey traffic signals, and ride in designated lanes when there is infrastructure dedicated to support them.

    In Chicago, when bike-specific traffic signals were installed, stoplight compliance rose from 31 percent to 81 percent. Moreover in DC and New York, when protected bicycle lanes were constructed cyclists decreased their usage of riding on sidewalks by 56 percent.

  • Reducing Traffic Congestion. Funding, designing, and constructing complete streets inclusive of protected bicycle lanes will result in reducing traffic congestion. More bike lanes translate to less automobiles taking up valuable street space, which translates into more buses, freight, and essential vehicles capable of more easily accessing the road.City planners in Austin understand this concept. In a recent proposal these folks recommended investing in a network of protected bike lanes to incentivize cycling as a viable transportation alternative to help alleviate traffic congestion and pollution. These city planners project that this network of protected bicycle lanes will increase the city’s traffic capacity by roughly 25,000 trips per day.
  • It’s the Economy, Stupid. A 2015 study revealed that driving a personal car in a city costs six times more than riding a bicycle. The study also found that the cost of driving a car in the future is likely to increase, while the cost of bicycling will likely decrease.The cost-benefit analysis framework used in this particular study compared the following factors between cars and bicycles, accidents, climate change, health, and travel time. While this study was focused on Copenhagen, Denmark, the researchers are encouraging urban planners in other major cities worldwide to consider adapting this framework to include the social costs and benefits between driving and bicycling.

    By adopting this modified analysis, advocates can more effectively make the case for increasing cycling infrastructure investments like traffic lights, protected bicycle lanes, tunnels and bridges.

City skyline

So, while it may seem like a pipe dream to ban personal cars in major cities worldwide, the personal and economic incentives are certainly compelling. What is good for personal and business gains in this instance is even better for the planet. Banning personal cars in city-centers results in less carbon emissions, which can significantly improve our chances of limiting the devastation of what we know is the inevitable if we fail to take reasoned action against climate change.

As a place to start, consider amplifying some of these points to your local leaders, city planners, or really, anyone who will listen. You are also welcome to share a few of your own reasons below as to why you believe cities would be better off with fewer personal cars on the roadways.

For the latest content and updates please follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Pinterest.

Rhodes Perry

Rhodes Perry

Rhodes is a writer, social justice advocate, and passionate cyclist. He primarily spends his time in the saddle commuting or riding multi-day, self-supported tours, and volunteers time wrenching at his local bike coop.


12 thoughts on “10 Reasons Why Cities Should Consider Going Car-Free”

    • Yes, it’s fantastic! Copenhagen will also get a car free day next year and I think Madrid will make the center of the city car-free by 2020.

  1. The warranties for some branded cars may go up to 3 or 4 years depending
    on the model. Now you will soon forget about key-fobs as
    well since new biometric revolution is going to allow you to enter your car with your fingerprint, face
    detection or eyeball recognition. It is available in two versions of petrol and
    diesel and has been a very reasonable price.

  2. WOW!great idea! I hope this gets implemented all over the world to save our mother earth from dying! Let’s aim for a pollution free Earth

  3. Think about the extra space to move if there were less cars, less parking spaces, less pollution, less environmental damage, less angry people, less unhealthy individuals…More money in your pocket saved from car related expenses

  4. In fact both petrol and electric cars should be banned. It might be weird to ban also electric car but the grid is far from ready to handle a huge increase in electrical cars, and resorting to nuclear power is not a renewable solution. Unless the grid is seriously updated it would be better to have electric public transportation but no electric cars.


Leave a Comment